The lack of consistent and reliable data makes measuring sustainability risks difficult, but not impossible. Our study Balancing sustainability shows that even on the basis of limited data it can be established that sustainability risks for the Dutch financial sector are material. In 2022 we will further clarify our expectations with regard to adequate management of these sustainability risks.
The study shows that the carbon footprint attributed to Dutch financial institutions’ global financing and investment operations is at least 82 Mtonnes, and probably more. For comparison: this number corresponds to about half of the total carbon emissions of the Dutch economy in 2019. Figure 1 shows that the carbon footprint of the Dutch financial sector is mainly attributable to exposures of pension funds (47 Mtonnes) and banks (30 Mtonnes). The transition to a carbon-neutral economy thus implies a material sustainability risk for financial institutions, commonly referred to as transition risk. For example, changes in government climate policy can give rise to increased credit and market risks due to unexpected or premature write-downs and impairment of their assets (stranded assets). The effectiveness of such policy strongly determines the magnitude of transition risks. A less strict climate policy does lead to smaller transition risks in the near term, but also requires more incisive government action in the future, resulting in greater transition risks.
The study also shows that the transition risk, and thus the risk of stranded assets, will continue to increase in the coming years. In the years ahead, the planned activities of firms in which pension funds and insurers invest will increasingly deviate from the transition path required to achieve the climate goals of the UN Paris Agreement. This does not mean, however, that investment in these companies must necessarily be reduced. For example, by means of voting at shareholders' meetings and shareholder engagement, financial institutions can encourage firms in which they invest to reduce their carbon-intensive activities and invest in low-carbon alternatives.
It is important that financial institutions do not wait to measure sustainability risks until ‘perfect data’ is available. Experience shows that data is actually improved through measurement of these risks. Inevitably, estimates and modelled data must be used for the time being until better and more harmonized data becomes available. In this context, the International Financial Reporting Standards Foundation (IFRS Foundation) recently announced the establishment of a Sustainability Standards Board , which seeks to consolidate several existing sustainability reporting initiatives into a single harmonised global reporting standard. In tandem with the ECB, we are also committed to developing harmonised standards and calculation methods to improve data quality in the field of sustainability.7
We supervise adequate risk management by financial institutions. The same applies to sustainability risk management. In 2022 we will further define how we expect financial institutions to manage sustainability risks. We will also consult the financial sector on this. We seek to align our expectations with the ECB’s guide to supervisory expectations for banks, which addresses the integration of sustainability into strategy, governance, risk management and reporting. We will also take the specific characteristics of non-banking Dutch financial institutions into account.
Report 'Balancing sustainability'
The vast majority of homeowners in the Netherlands have sufficient savings or could take out a loan to make their home more climate-friendly. They can afford to upgrade their home insulation to energy label B and install a heat pump.
Read more Almost all Dutch homeowners able to finance climate measures
Dutch banks risk losses from coastal and river flooding through their loans to businesses. Flood measures such as dykes and storm surge barriers mitigate most of the risk, even as climate change increases flood risks. Without flood measures, expected losses would total more than €2.5 billion a year.
Read more Dutch banks' exposure to flood risks through corporate lending is limited
The market for Dutch green securitisations of residential mortgages and for green covered bonds more than tripled in size in 2023 compared to 2022, DNB figures show, reflecting investor demand for green investments.
Read more Sharp increase in green securitisations in 2023
At her keynote address at the CMPI-IOSCO workshop today, Inge van Dijk (Director Payments, Cash & Market Infrastructure, De Nederlandsche Bank) said Financial Market Infrastructures could do more to integrate climate risk in their risk management.
Read more Climate risk: what does it mean for you?
